• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

NetFamilyNews.org

Kid tech intel for everybody

Show Search
Hide Search
  • Home
  • Youth
  • Parenting
  • Literacy
  • Safety
  • Policy
  • Research
  • About NetFamilyNews.org
    • Supporters
    • Anne Collier’s Bio
    • Copyright
    • Privacy

Wellbeing, digital or analog: A paper, a podcast

January 17, 2019 By Anne 3 Comments

Confused about all that you’re hearing about the impacts of digital media and tech on young people? A just-published paper should clear that confusion up, reports Scientific American.

Drawing from data on more than 350,000 teens, the paper, “show[s] persuasively that…technology use has a nearly negligible effect on adolescent psychological well-being.” Its authors, Oxford University researchers Amy Orben and Andrew Przybylski, took a whole range of wellbeing-related questions to that data – “depressive symptoms, suicidal ideation, pro-social behavior, peer-relationship problems and the like” – and found that “technology use tilts the needle less than half a percent away from feeling emotionally sound,” writes ScientificAmerican.com reporter Lydia Denworth. “For context, eating potatoes is associated with nearly the same degree of effect and wearing glasses has a more negative impact on adolescent mental health.”

I’d seen coverage of the paper, just published in the journal Nature, tweeted by a number of researchers but was linked to this Scientific American report by social science professor David Finkelhor at University of New Hampshire. He was responding to a question I’d put to researchers in a discussion group because I wanted to check with them on a statement about young people’s use of technology made by computer science professor Cal Newport in an otherwise thoughtful podcast by journalist Ezra Klein.

Had I read the research wrong?

Was I crazy? My understanding of the research was that there’s so much we don’t know yet, and there’s certainly nothing definitive on the negative impacts of digital media on youth, yet I was hearing Dr. Newport saying that the research shows social media causes loneliness in teens and referring to “a 19-year-old who never leaves his room,” but thinks he’s socializing because he’s using social media…as descriptive of teen socializing in the digital age.

Well, it’s not. First, researchers say it’s not – see the above paper. Second, as probably everybody who knows, loves and works with teenagers will tell you, “social” for most teens is first and foremost a “real life” thing. Media plays a supporting role to that. Social media, including videogames, is about their friends, not about technology. Third, as Denworth reports, “effects really do depend on the user.” It’s individual. Certainly there are young people struggling with social disorders who feel more comfortable keeping things online and not leaving their room, but very, very few. If they do, technology is not likely the main problem.

‘Digital de-cluttering’

But it was a great podcast, otherwise. I appreciated Newport’s definition of “solitude” as freedom from the outputs of other minds, which I think deepens the conversation. In the podcast and probably in his new book Digital Minimalism, Newport talks about giving ourselves time for reflection – a chance to process all that we’re taking in. And helping our children value that. Yes, absolutely, we want to help them think critically about the tech and media they use, and it goes even deeper than that to helping them think about what they value.

I like that Newport uses the term “digital de-cluttering,” rather than “de-toxing.” De-cluttering is not just critical thinking. It’s not, or shouldn’t be merely transactional – what do I gain if I delete this, etc. – but rather transformational. We can make it a self-reflection, or even self-knowledge, tool – a way to get a better handle on what we value most and what analog and digital activities serve that. “What is the best way to use technology to support this value?” is the question Newport suggests we ask. A good question for personal inquiry and family discussion, right?

Related links

  • “We’re all looking in the wrong direction. The real threat isn’t smartphones. It’s this campaign of misinformation and the generation of fear among parents and educators,” Scientific American quoted Candice Odgers, a researcher in adolescent health and technology at University of California, Irvine, as saying. I just wanted to highlight that quote from the very end of the article. Here’s Odgers’s 2015 paper referred to in the article: “Seven fears and the science of how mobile technologies may be influencing adolescents in the digital age”
  • “Screens might be as bad for mental health as…potatoes” – Wired’s coverage of the paper, and…
  • Here again is this groundbreaking paper by Orben and Przybylski: “The association between adolescent well-being and digital technology use” at Nature.com
  • About Cal Newport’s new book Digital Minimalism
Share Button

Filed Under: Research, Youth Tagged With: Amy Orben, Andrew Przybylski, Cal Newport, Candice Odgers, David Finkelhor, Ezra Klain, Nature, Oxford University

Reader Interactions

Trackbacks

  1. Amid all the talk of teens and ‘digital wellbeing’… - NetFamilyNews.org says:
    August 8, 2022 at 6:44 am

    […] About a paper on social media effects by Orben and Andrew Przybylski at Oxfor University that got a great deal of media attention: “Wellbeing, digital or analog: A paper, a podcast“ […]

    Reply
  2. How our kids can become 'indistractable' - NetFamilyNews.org says:
    June 18, 2021 at 11:29 am

    […] time for traction (think about what they value and how they want to spend their time to serve that). [We parents need to honor that, Eyal writes. […]

    Reply
  3. Sharing Diigo Links and Resources (weekly) | Another EducatorAl Blog says:
    January 21, 2019 at 10:23 pm

    […] Wellbeing, digital or analog: A paper, a podcast – NetFamilyNews.org […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

NFN in your in-box:

Anne Collier


Bio and my...
2016 TEDx Talk on
the heart of digital citizenship

Subscribe to my
RSS feed
Follow me on Twitter or even better:
NEW: Follow me on MASTODON!
Friend me on Facebook
See me on YouTube

IMPORTANT RESOURCES

Our (DIGITAL) PARENTING BASICS: Safety + Social
NAMLE, the National Association for Media Literacy Education
CASEL.org & the 5 core social-emotional competencies of SEL
Center for Democracy & Technology
Center for Innovative Public Health Research
Childnet International
Committee for Children
Congressional Internet Caucus Academy
ConnectSafely.org
Control Shift: a pivotal book for Internet safety
Crimes Against Children Research Center
Crisis Textline
Cyber Civil Rights Initiative's Revenge Porn Crisis Line
Cyberwise.org
danah boyd's blog and book about networked youth
Disconnected, Carrie James's book on digital ethics
FOSI.org's Good Digital Parenting
The research of Global Kids Online
The Good Project at Harvard's School of Education
If you watch nothing else: "Parenting in a Digital Age" TED Talk by Prof. Sonia Livingstone
The International Bullying Prevention Association
Let Grow Foundation
Making Caring Common
Raising Digital Natives, author Devorah Heitner's site
Renee Hobbs at the Media Education Lab
MediaSmarts.ca
The New Media Literacies
Report of the Aspen Task Force on Learning & the Internet and our guide to Creating Trusted Learning Environments
The Ruler Approach to social-emotional learning (Yale Center for Emotional Intelligence)
Sources of Strength
"Young & Online: Perspectives on life in a digital age" from young people in 26 countries (via UNICEF)
"Youth Safety on a Living Internet": 2010 report of the Online Safety & Technology Working Group (and my post about it)

Categories

Recent Posts

  • A solution for ‘awful but lawful’
  • New global service for getting nudes off the Internet
  • Then there’s the flip side of ChatGPT
  • For SID 2023: What youth want ‘online safety’ to teach
  • ChatGPT for media literacy training
  • Future safety: Content moderators and digital grassroots justice
  • Mental health 2023, Part 1: Youth on algorithms
  • Where did my Twitter go? And other end-of-2022 notes

Footer

Welcome to NetFamilyNews!

Founded as a nonprofit public service in 1999, NetFamilyNews quickly became the “community newspaper” of a vital interest community of subscribers in more than 50 countries. Site and newsletter became a blog in the early 2000s. Nowadays, you can subscribe in the box to the right to receive articles in your in-box as they're posted – or look for tweets, posts on our Facebook page, and key commentaries from Anne on her page at Medium.com. She welcomes your comments, follows and shares!

Categories

  • Home
  • Youth
  • Parenting
  • Literacy
  • Safety
  • Policy
  • Research

ABOUT

  • About NFN
  • Supporters
  • Anne Collier’s Bio
  • Copyright
  • Privacy

Search

Subscribe



THANKS TO NETFAMILYNEWS.ORG's SUPPORTER HOMESCHOOL CURRICULUM.
Copyright © 2023 ANNE COLLIER. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.