• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

NetFamilyNews.org

Kid tech intel for everybody

Show Search
Hide Search
  • Home
  • Youth
  • Parenting
  • Literacy
  • Safety
  • Policy
  • Research
  • About NetFamilyNews.org
    • Supporters
    • Anne Collier’s Bio
    • Copyright
    • Privacy

Consider the possibility of kids’ self-regulation of digital media

April 9, 2013 By Anne 15 Comments

Are iPads bad for little children? I ask that metaphorically, for two reasons: because iPads represent a host of tablets and other touchscreen devices children seem to play with joyfully and intuitively, and because that attraction makes it extra hard to imagine kids could self-regulate that iPad play. And yet they do.

Take Gideon, for example (“Giddy” to himself and his family). In some of the best reporting I’ve seen on kids and technology hands down, Giddy’s mom Hanna Rosin – national correspondent at The Atlantic – tells what happened with him and “his” iPad when he wasn’t quite 2 years old. His first app was Talking Baby Hippo, in which the pudgy protagonist would laugh when Giddy poked it on the screen. “At first [Gideon] would get frustrated trying to zoom between screens, or not knowing what to do when a message popped up. But after about two weeks, he figured all that out,” Rosin writes in a thorough, thoughtful article. Even though Giddy’s story (I’ll get to the good part in a second) is only a tiny piece of it, it illustrates a notion I think it would behoove us parents to entertain: that our children have some built-in self-regulation capabilities, that it’s not strictly up to us to regulate and enwisen them and that it’s good to look for and nurture those tendencies.

The fascinating part of Giddy’s story

Rosin thought she’d test out Marc Prensky’s “extreme parenting philosophy” – the one that says requiring kids to consume text in books instead of interact with content on screens is more about believing in (maybe clinging to) where we came from than where we are right now. So he treats all of his son’s media the same – books, TV, apps, whatever. It got Rosin herself to wonder if “books [are] always, in every situation, inherently better than screens?” Her other kids are 9 and 12, and her daughter, “after all, uses books as a way to avoid social interaction, while my son uses the Wii to bond with friends.”

So she decided to conduct an experiment, she wrote: “For six months, I would let my toddler live by the Prensky rules. I would put the iPad in the toy basket, along with the remote-control car and the Legos. Whenever he wanted to play with it, I would let him.” Her account of what happened was a lot like what we experienced in our family with an 11-year-old after getting his first Xbox 360 console and games. There was a slightly obsessive quality to Gideon’s iPad and my son’s Xbox play for a while. Then we experienced something quite similar to what Rosin describes: “After about 10 days [it took longer for us, but there wasn’t quite the same level of obsession], the iPad fell out of his rotation, just like every other toy does. He dropped it under the bed and never looked for it. It was completely forgotten for about six weeks. Now he picks it up every once in a while, but not all that often.”

As you think about that, keep in mind that it wasn’t like Gideon was getting bored with just one toy. The variety and number of apps available for the iPad make it so that the iPad is a bundle of many toys, and Gideon tired of the whole package.

Do try this at home?

It wouldn’t go like that for all kids, of course, but it’d probably be hard to find out. Because in these times of overparenting – with all the pressure there is on parents to get every detail right (however that’s defined) – there aren’t many experiments like Rosin’s being conducted in American households. Can we allow enough time to see if our kids will self-regulate (i.e., get bored with the device or medium in question) before we intervene?

Rosin cites the view of Sandra Calvert, director of the Children’s Media Center at Georgetown University, that it’s not like these media and devices are going away. By three years ago (2010), “two-thirds of children ages 4 to 7 had used an iPhone, according to the Joan Ganz Cooney Center, which studies children’s media,” she writes. So the question of whether touchscreens are bad for kids is academic, as they say, and academics like Calvert have moved on to ask how kids learn and have fun using apps on touchscreens. [See also my post on the Joan Ganz Cooney Center’s study about younger kids’ social media use.]

Sidebar: Are we passing on our biases?

In her research for the article, Rosin talked with parents observing how their kids were playing with apps on iPads and felt she’d tapped into “the neurosis of our age: as technology becomes ubiquitous in our lives American parents are becoming more, not less, wary of what it might be doing to their children.” Later she mentions the book Screen Time, by journalist Lisa Guernsey, who wrote something in sync with findings by researchers at Harvard looking into young people’s attitudes toward media. “Two sentiments we heard from a lot of young people,” Carrie James, director of the research project said: that “the Internet is simply for fun” (therefore inconsequential) and that “they feel a lack of efficacy online – if they see something unsettling they tend to ignore it or move on because they don’t feel they can change anything online.”

Where could the young survey respondents could’ve gotten that? Guernsey may have the answer. Rosin writes that “one of the most interesting points Guernsey makes is about the importance of parents’ attitudes toward media. If they treat screen time like junk food, or ‘like a magazine at the hair salon’—good for passing the time in a frivolous way but nothing more—then the child will fully absorb that attitude, and the neurosis will be passed to the next generation.”

Share Button

Filed Under: Parenting, Social Media Tagged With: child development, children, digital media, digital play, digital tools, Hanna Rosin, iPads, Parenting, tablets, The Atlantic, youth

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Will Richardson says

    April 12, 2013 at 11:04 am

    Thanks for the responses.

    I wish I could be as carefree about it as Prensky and not feel like I have to regulate it. Or, I wish I would have been as consistent about the regulation early on as you seem to have been Lisa. This messy middle is fraught with angst and uncertainty. I think my biggest failure as a parent is a lack of consistency and even communication with my kids about the expectations. It seems like a constant struggle. Ugh, teenagers!

    Reply
  2. Lisa Noble says

    April 11, 2013 at 5:46 pm

    Such smart stuff (the article, and the comments). As both an elementary school teacher, and a parent of 10 and 12 year old boys, I want a support group, like Will does, but I’m also a little disturbed by the tendency of my younger students (I teach Grade 4-8) to see the device in their pocket exclusively as a toy. I encourage my students to bring their devices to class, so we can research, or share ideas with a brainstorming tool, or take notes, or contribute to a co-operative activity….so that they can see the Internet, and the device that they access it with as something other than a consumable. Many of my students who have laptops as part of their learning plan are the ones I need to pry off Youtube and gaming to have them use the device for something collaborative with the class – the 10 day rule is not working here.

    My own kids are currently Minecraft addicts (they do have time limits) – but there’s also a healthy dose of Scratch in there, and one of my favourite times of the week is one night a week at the Y – older boy has judo, I have a hi/low class, and younger boy and a couple of other friends spend some time in drop-in gym, then gather around a laptop and teach each other stuff. Last week,they made a movie (credits and all) on MovieMaker; another night, they build a game on Scratch. It’s terrifically collaborative, there’s tons of learning going on, and they’re social like crazy, face to face.

    So far, I’m not having to do a lot of worrying about Facebook and Insta – they know they have to check with us about downloading apps, and neither has accounts yet. Neither has a smartphone yet, and I think that makes a difference.

    I grew up with an hour a day screen time limit for TV – I had to decide what I wanted to watch. My kids have the same limit – they like to break it into 15-20 minute chunks. My younger guy has discovered that he feels ill and grumpy if he spends a longer chunk of time on screen, which helps. I try to model the same thing during my at-home time (which is a challenge). Learning to make choices about your time is a life skill, I think.

    Reply
    • Anne says

      April 11, 2013 at 11:24 pm

      Thanks for your comment, Lisa. Lots of great parenting pointers in there! I love how you illustrate how many types of uses there are for a single device or screen (I’m not sure how people can still generalize about some sort of undifferentiated “screen time”) and how different kids need different kinds and levels of “help with self-regulation,” as Will put it. “Y Night” is a great idea – better, I think, than just unplug night (or sabbath or shabbat, etc.). Though there’s certainly nothing wrong with the latter, it has become a bit of a cliché, and why not do something for positive reasons? Did you happen to see my post about BYOT in the Forsyth County (Ga.) school district? Wonder if their experience makes sense to you. Tx again.

      Reply
  3. Will Richardson says

    April 11, 2013 at 2:53 pm

    “…OR a support group.”

    Reply
  4. Will Richardson says

    April 11, 2013 at 2:52 pm

    Hey Anne,

    Just wondering what if anything changes when it becomes more than a toy and a social connection instead. My struggle now as a parent is helping my kids self-regulate FB, twitter, Instagram and Minecraft. I’ve been giving my kids the room to set their own limits, but…let’s just say it’s been more than 10 days.

    Definitely not getting all the details right at this point. Looking for the Manual 2.0 on a support group. ;0)

    Thanks for the consistently great stuff you’re writing and sharing.

    Reply
    • Anne says

      April 11, 2013 at 3:07 pm

      Thanks kindly for your comment, Will. I get the feeling every parent’s looking for Manual 2.0 (or a support group) right now – goes with the media-shift territory, it seems. Every family and every kid within a family is so individual that it’s pretty impossible to make generalizations about how to help kids self-regulate. Some are better than others at it (or have other interests beyond socializing) that help them. I suspect it’s a balance between self- and parental regulation that changes with maturity and gets calibrated based on mutual communication and trust. One of your kids may need more help from you than the other – for a while, perhaps – because it’s not just individual, it’s also situational, depending on what’s going on in their peer groups, right? None of this is anything you don’t already know, but what I try to remember is what I’m reminded of by my amazing friends who teach in virtual worlds and digital games like Minecraft (not to mention James Paul Gee), is that mistakes or trial and error are essential to progress and learning in games and in life.

      Reply
    • Anne says

      April 11, 2013 at 11:49 pm

      Will, I had an afterthought about self-regulation that I’d love to run by you: that what we parents sometimes forget to factor in is the huge difference between our media experience growing up and our children’s. A friend of mine said one of his children is an avid reader (read the Harry Potter series before age 7), while another kept losing books she was given to read. So he gave the latter a tablet to read books on, and she figured out how to listen to the books rather than read them. That raised a question rather than a reaction (maybe it’s helpful, under the shifted media and other conditions we now face as families, to work a question “out loud” with our kids, when one comes up, rather than have a predetermined response or decision that “this is the way we do things”?). My friend’s question was simply whether reading or listening to a book is better if the former gives rise to avoidance and the latter doesn’t – it’s still the same book. Who knows? Depends on the kid, the context, etc. But that dad’s question (along with your and Lisa’s comments) illustrate for me that (to borrow John Seely Brown’s metaphor) parenting, just like learning, is now more like whitewater kayaking than piloting a steamship. Though a lot of the wisdom, values, etc. we got from our parents is the same, we’re also working more from/with tacit knowledge we gain and act on as we go rather than from the explicit knowledge of “this is the way we’ve always done it.” You know?

      Reply

Trackbacks

  1. ADHD: It’s More Than Just Too Much Sugar and Screen Time (the root is in the gut) – Healthy Good Life says:
    November 14, 2018 at 1:56 am

    […] is why some people are so adamantly pro-self-regulation with media,and why others insist that their children require strict formation when it comes to media. My […]

    Reply
  2. ADHD: It's More Than Just Too Much Sugar and Screen Time (the root is in the gut) | WOMANS HEALTH WITH MEGAN says:
    October 31, 2018 at 10:12 pm

    […] is why some people are so adamantly pro-self-regulation with media, and why others insist that their children need strict structure when it comes to media.  My […]

    Reply
  3. ADHD: It’s More Than Just Too Much Sugar and Screen Time (the root is in the gut) – EarthySpirit.com says:
    October 28, 2018 at 6:26 am

    […] is why some people are so adamantly pro-self-regulation with media,and why others insist that “their childrens” requirement strict structure when it comes […]

    Reply
  4. ADHD: It’s More Than Just Too Much Sugar and Screen Time (the root is in the gut) - Peek Baby says:
    October 28, 2018 at 12:59 am

    […] is why some people are so adamantly pro-self-regulation with media, and why others insist that their children need strict structure when it comes to media.  My […]

    Reply
  5. ADHD: It's More Than Just Too Much Sugar and Screen Time (the root is in the gut) says:
    October 27, 2018 at 11:00 pm

    […] is why some people are so adamantly pro-self-regulation with media,and why others insist that “their childrens” requirement strict arrangement when it […]

    Reply
  6. Children's library-on-a-tablet - NetFamilyNews.org | NetFamilyNews.org says:
    March 2, 2014 at 9:53 am

    […] About little Gideon and his tablet, as told by his mom, author and journalist Hanna Rosin […]

    Reply
  7. Kids, Instagram & its new feature 'Photos of You' | NetFamilyNews.org says:
    May 3, 2013 at 3:32 pm

    […] “Consider the possibility of kids’ self-regulation of digital media” […]

    Reply
  8. Definitely not just because of Windows 8 | NetFamilyNews.org says:
    April 12, 2013 at 1:52 am

    […] means that parenting has turned a corner too. As I mentioned in response to educator Will Richardson’s comment in my blog this week, going forward, working through things “out loud” (transparently) with our kids rather […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

NFN in your in-box:

Anne Collier


Bio and my...
2016 TEDx Talk on
the heart of digital citizenship

Connect with me on LinkedIn
Follow me on MASTODON
Friend me on Facebook
See me on YouTube

IMPORTANT RESOURCES

Our (DIGITAL) PARENTING BASICS: Safety + Social
NAMLE, the National Association for Media Literacy Education
CASEL.org & the 5 core social-emotional competencies of SEL
Center for Democracy & Technology
Center for Innovative Public Health Research
Childnet International
Committee for Children
Congressional Internet Caucus Academy
ConnectSafely.org
Control Shift: a pivotal book for Internet safety
Crimes Against Children Research Center
Crisis Textline
Cyber Civil Rights Initiative's Revenge Porn Crisis Line
Cyberwise.org
danah boyd's blog and book about networked youth
Disconnected, Carrie James's book on digital ethics
FOSI.org's Good Digital Parenting
The research of Global Kids Online
The Good Project at Harvard's School of Education
If you watch nothing else: "Parenting in a Digital Age" TED Talk by Prof. Sonia Livingstone
The International Bullying Prevention Association
Let Grow Foundation
Making Caring Common
Raising Digital Natives, author Devorah Heitner's site
Renee Hobbs at the Media Education Lab
MediaSmarts.ca
The New Media Literacies
Report of the Aspen Task Force on Learning & the Internet and our guide to Creating Trusted Learning Environments
The Ruler Approach to social-emotional learning (Yale Center for Emotional Intelligence)
Sources of Strength
"Young & Online: Perspectives on life in a digital age" from young people in 26 countries (via UNICEF)
"Youth Safety on a Living Internet": 2010 report of the Online Safety & Technology Working Group (and my post about it)

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Safety by co-design: How we can take youth online safety to the next level
  • Much-less-social media on Facebook’s 20th birthday
  • What child online safety really needs, senators
  • Welcome to 2024!
  • Supporting the youngest witnesses of this humanitarian crisis
  • Should our kids learn how to use generative AI? Well…
  • The missing piece in US child online safety law
  • Generative AI: July 2023 freeze frame

Footer

Welcome to NetFamilyNews!

Founded as a nonprofit public service in 1999, NetFamilyNews quickly became the “community newspaper” of a vital interest community of subscribers in more than 50 countries. Site and newsletter became a blog in the early 2000s. Nowadays, you can subscribe in the box to the right to receive articles in your in-box as they're posted – or look for toots on Mastodon or posts on our Facebook page, LinkedIn and Medium.com. She welcomes your comments, follows and shares!

Categories

  • Home
  • Youth
  • Parenting
  • Literacy
  • Safety
  • Policy
  • Research

ABOUT

  • About NFN
  • Supporters
  • Anne Collier’s Bio
  • Copyright
  • Privacy

Search

Subscribe



THANKS TO NETFAMILYNEWS.ORG's SUPPORTER HOMESCHOOL CURRICULUM.
Copyright © 2025 ANNE COLLIER. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.